What improvements and changes would the r/conspiracy community like to see in this subreddit?
15 2012-11-08 by [deleted]
Self explanatory title really, this is an open message to our community for feedback and suggestions on how the page can be moved forward.
We approach 100,000, this is a significant number. So, this is an opportunity for everyone to give us feedback, tell us your ideas and thoughts about how we can continue to improve the /r/conspiracy page.
We are open to suggestions and criticism, we want the community to understand that we listen and ultimately it is the community that drives us forward.
Your thoughts are appreciated and welcome.
MrDong
76 comments
6 Weedtastic 2012-11-08
Less racist Bullshit (solution: change rule 1 to no racism)
Keeping an open mind
More Thinking
Downvotes simply because you disagree.
We should try to make this Subreddit really a thinking ground.
We should offer some sort of "Solution" to fight back against the TPTB (The Powers that be).
5 [deleted] 2012-11-08
Rule one already changed. Good observation.
1 Weedtastic 2012-11-08
Great to see a change!
-1 hotakyuu 2012-11-08
I said that too, and OP is asking me for proof of said racism and accusing me of making reports. Watch out, man. EDIT, actually I said antisemitism, and the OP in our comment thread was the first to use the word racist. Interest-thing.
4 Weedtastic 2012-11-08
Dude come down a bit lol
Mr Dong want only a example (which i did now post for you).
There is no "conspiracy" Mr Dong is a nice guy.
-4 hotakyuu 2012-11-08
He asked how many posts I have reported for racism. That is unnecessary and insinuates I have done such a thing. The entire convo was changed from the problems with this sub to me personally, and that is bullshit debate tactics.
2 [deleted] 2012-11-08
No it hasn't, you raised your concerns, i acknowledged you and asked you what posts you have had any issues with regarding racism. It was a direct question, not an accusation!
-3 hotakyuu 2012-11-08
What is the point in asking that? There isn't one. Besides, you still switch this to me personally and that is still a really shitty thing to do.
6 [deleted] 2012-11-08
What is a shitty thing to do? Answering your statement with a simple question?!
-2 hotakyuu 2012-11-08
Yup. You turned it into a "reporting button user witch hunt". ;)
4 [deleted] 2012-11-08
I think you have missed the point of this post. I haven't downvoted anyone and welcome your opinion. Forgive me for asking you a couple of questions regarding your concerns!
-3 hotakyuu 2012-11-08
Asking me "How many posts have you reported for racism" is completely off topic from the problem of racism itself. Now you want to play all innocent since I called you out on that bullshit post. Well, glad you can eat some humble pie at least.
1 [deleted] 2012-11-08
I haven't eaten any 'umble pie', it was a simple enough question. The rules are the same for everyone. If you have an issue or feel a post is inappropriate for whatever reason you should message the moderators. I'm not always here so i was interested to know how many times you have reported posts for racism in the past.
You haven't reported any have you?
-2 hotakyuu 2012-11-08
/facedesk
LOL
You're doing it again!
Lousy!
2 [deleted] 2012-11-08
Another downvote. I will spare you the same. Thanks for commenting.
1 [deleted] 2012-11-08
I'll just go along with the other posters who have commented;
You're being downvoted for being dense and intentionally being complicated. I would nearly guarantee that MrDong is not down voting you. But I would nearly guarantee that you're down voting him.
1 hotakyuu 2012-11-08
The downvote that was on my original comment was undone. Too bad I did not get a screen shot
-5 tttt0tttt 2012-11-08
If you're condemning comments that you think are racist, maybe your mind isn't as open as you believe. It's very closed-minded to dismiss opinions with the "racist" label. It's a sign of intolerance.
4 [deleted] 2012-11-08
There are comments made here that are racist.
2 Weedtastic 2012-11-08
look i talk about zionism but when the comments are only "the jews rule the world" "he is a jew he is in the conspiracy" without good evidence that is only racist and i don't discuss with racist people.
4 Orangutan 2012-11-08
More 9/11 Truth
4 [deleted] 2012-11-08
You were down-voted for offering your opinion. Says a great deal about what we are up against. Thank you for your comment Orangutan!
4 [deleted] 2012-11-08
I'd like to see:
I really hate that people who try to encourage thinking about every possible solution are demolished by down votes because they're not just going along with the status-quo of the sub.
3 BadgerGecko 2012-11-08
I have no idea how to enforce but basic redetiquette would improve things greatly.
3 SilentNick3 2012-11-08
Less anti semitism. For examples, see anything posted by bumblingmumbling, tttt0tttt, most of what Occidentalist posts, and a few others.
2 bakedphilosopher 2012-11-08
What if i post things conspiracy theories involving jews?
-4 [deleted] 2012-11-08
[deleted]
4 [deleted] 2012-11-08
Bumblingmumbling quite often (as well as Ijob911) posts about being anti-Jew, not just anti-Zion.
2 SilentNick3 2012-11-08
Yeah, I and many others would say you are actually anti Semitic. Nearly anyone who checks out your and those others' post histories (and who doesn't believe the whole "Jews run the world" BS) would agree. It's why your posts about such subjects are rarely taken seriously anywhere, except /r/conspiracy and /r/worldpolitics
It isn't what I do with my day at all. A couple minutes of browsing the above mentioned subs and a few others leads me to such anti Semitism spouted by you. For fuck's sake, your username is a goddamn Menorah. Either way, I work 40 hours a week and have a few hobbies, plus a fiancee, so my day is filled with far more than "scouring reddit" for anything.
No such file exists, but please don't act like it is wrong to link to bigoted posts made by you and your bigoted brethren and act like I am the one doing something wrong. Again, the proof is in your post history. Delete your comments and/or account if you are so ashamed of them.
Again, I have plenty of hobbies. It's kind of pathetic that you fall back on a variation of the classic failed internet comeback of saying I waste all my time on this. Gonna call me a basement dweller while you're at it?
0 kyr 2012-11-08
Of course, you only hate Jews because they oppress poor, helpless racists like you. Clearly the Holocaust deniers are the victims here.
4 [deleted] 2012-11-08
[deleted]
4 kyr 2012-11-08
You wouldn't have to deal with personal attacks if your person wasn't so utterly despicable.
You at least make an attempt to hide your antisemitism behind Zionism, though I think even the subscribers of /r/conspiracy aren't stupid enough to fall for that.
2 [deleted] 2012-11-08
[deleted]
3 kyr 2012-11-08
Hmm, I dunno. Could it be me? Oh, I know, it's the guy who thinks those Jews were totally asking for it .
1 SilentNick3 2012-11-08
We call you an anti-semite because you say things about ALL JEWS. What part of that do you not understand? Or do you enjoy hiding behind "anti-Zionism" as a front for being essentially a Nazi?
2 [deleted] 2012-11-08
[deleted]
2 Hamlet7768 2012-11-08
Right, because saying Hitler was actually in the right and denying the Holocaust isn't damn close to Nazism.
1 bakedphilosopher 2012-11-08
I agree with tot, bumbling et al. How.come.i can be proudly jewish and not.find them.offensive? So many conspiracy theories involve jews directly. The Rothschilds, the zionist lobby, the unacceptable amount of support israel gets. Why is it anti-semetic to expose the disgraceful loyalty diaspora jews have to israel instead of the countries they were born in. If anything should be changed on r/conspiracy, its that people should not be allowed to accuse others of being "anti-semetic" just because they are fed up with rich zionist criminals like adelson and bloomberg and silverstein. It sickens them that their leaders.brown nose a sandbox the size of delaware. Im jewish It pisses me off too. So stop calling people anti-semites.
1 [deleted] 2012-11-08
I understand and it is uncalled for, it is tiresome for the mods. We can only ask that people who post choose their words carefully and not descend into race hate - which most of our posters don't.
2 Fits_the_profile 2012-11-08
Less "political correctness".
Less image spam.
More merging of dupe posts by mods.
More banning or flagging of known shills/trolls.
2 kyr 2012-11-08
Merging is not a thing mods can do. The only way would be to completely remove dupes, but that would also remove any separate discussion unless done before any comments are made.
1 [deleted] 2012-11-08
Especially the banning point.
1 haveyouconsideredthe 2012-11-08
Let the voting handle that unless they are spamming.
Banning someone for having a different opinion is a shitty thing to do in a subreddit that proclaims it " respect everyone's opinions and ALL religious beliefs and creeds"
2 Sandy_106 2012-11-08
Please get rid of posts that are only news, and not really conspiracy.
http://www.reddit.com/r/conspiracy/comments/12vtwx/fema_office_on_staten_island_closes_due_to_weather/
http://www.reddit.com/r/conspiracy/comments/12uphm/bradley_manning_indicates_he_would_accept/
http://www.reddit.com/r/conspiracy/comments/12v71p/obamas_secret_weapon_rush_limbaugh_urges_the_gop/
For example.
2 haveyouconsideredthe 2012-11-08
ban yrugay. He just spams threads with pointless lists 90% of the time. He even posted the list from "related stories" as a comment today.
2 Malizulu 2012-11-08
Dude, that's a bot. And those links are great resources.
3 haveyouconsideredthe 2012-11-08
Its not an actual bot, just a person pretending to be one.
2 horse_spelunker 2012-11-08
Kick out the nazis.
2 Malizulu 2012-11-08
More intellectual and engaging discussions. Less hatred. Less patronizing.
MORE SOURCES.
1 jblunted 2012-11-08
This this this. even if you disagree don't just say "You're perspective is fucking stupid".
1 youngcynic 2012-11-08
More challenging standards, like no mundane stories, memes, endless tomes of blog fluff, and just a change in the culture here that if there's an explainable and somewhat reasonable answer to something strange happening, you are encouraged and upvoted for posting it. One subreddit that does really well there is Glitch in the Matrix. Because whatever their rules are all about, it seems to work for Glitch.
1 [deleted] 2012-11-08
[deleted]
1 [deleted] 2012-11-08
I would like to change this too, it's bland, and counter productive. I will bring to the other mods attention.
0 hotakyuu 2012-11-08
Less propaganda posters.
Less Illuminati bullshit
Less anti semetic bullshit
More actual conspiracies
3 [deleted] 2012-11-08
Propaganda posters aimed towards who's benefit?
Less Illuminati BS vague considering that many conspiratorial topics have elitist/secret society ideas and themes.
What conspiracy theories are we not covering exactly, do you have any suggestions?
-3 hotakyuu 2012-11-08
Doesn't matter who the perceived beneficiary is, they are just annoying.
Yes, but the Illuminati is getting pre-tty old to hear about; it is akin to chasing the dragon.
Of what, a non antisemetic conspiracy?
I don't know, that's for you guys to find out. I'm just sick of the same old bull shit.
3 [deleted] 2012-11-08
Pretty vague answers here. Without any specific examples, especially of supposed anti-semitic posts it is quite hard to see what you're getting at.
Please feel free to point out any posts that could be considered racist.
-2 hotakyuu 2012-11-08
If you haven't seen it then you haven't spent enough time here.
Ain't nobody got time for that. Just read around.
3 [deleted] 2012-11-08
How many posts have you reported for racism?
6 Weedtastic 2012-11-08
This is one of many example (read all comments):
http://de.reddit.com/r/conspiracy/comments/12hrxf/do_you_not_know_anything_about_zionism/
4 [deleted] 2012-11-08
Agreed. However this is the nature of this subreddit. Racism is one thing and opinion and free thought are the other. This is where downvoting and upvoting have to come into play.
I don't have to agree with what an individual says, but they do have the right to say it, and argue their point don't they?
2 Weedtastic 2012-11-08
i did have with a moderator the same discussion about 2 racist comments i did report:
In my view this post's(and these are a small example) are still racism and should be forbidden.But i understand your point. I don't want to censor "Jewish Zionism" post's either but when its Hatefull Speech against jews there is the line crossed.
I Personally call it "Rothschild Zionism" because its controlled and payed by them. I am still trying to discuss this here in /r/conspiracy but it results in massive Downvoting,discussion's are ending in insults and white supremecy stuff.
Completly Agree
Change Rule 1 to "no racism" and you still can have discussion about Zionism but not Racism.
3 [deleted] 2012-11-08
The line is indeed a fine one and you sum up the point well. Rule one has already been changed. We do not hate any one group of people and certainly not the Jewish. However we will challenge any group that hides behind religion and uses an ideology as a tool for further control. That is the difference and it's a major one. We try to challenge evil men and evil institutions, not religions or faiths.
1 Weedtastic 2012-11-08
The one thing Joe biden said the truth:
"I am a Zionist.You Dont Have To Be Jewish To Be A Zionist" - Joe biden
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=1vDx-5b7T8M#t=52s
3 [deleted] 2012-11-08
Zionism is a parasite that has hijacked a religion to further a hidden, darker agenda.
2 [deleted] 2012-11-08
Yes, but you aren't automatically Jewish for being a Zionist, nor are you automatically a Zionist for being Jewish.
1 horse_spelunker 2012-11-08
I really do not think there's anything valuable to gain by giving racists a soapbox for their hate speech.
edit: personally, when I first came to reddit I checked out the conspiracy subreddit because I like reading about these things. I quickly unsubscribed though, because it was full of such toxic people and opinions. I'm just one person but there's an example of how racism can turn away potential subscribers.
0 tttt0tttt 2012-11-08
but they do have the right to say it, and argue their point don't they?
LOL, not according to some posters in this subreddit, they don't. These censorious posters want certain points of view eliminted, certain opinions hidden from view, certain ideas banned from the discussion. I'm surprised they haven't already won in this subreddit, as they have over most of Reddit, but I guess it's because the mods here continue to believe that free speech is something to be valued. But they are never going to stop, you know. They are going to keep chipping away until they get the censorship they are lusting after. Fanatics never stop pursuing their fanatical goals.
2 cock_blockula 2012-11-08
From the thread linked to it seems you speak from personal experience there.
0 hotakyuu 2012-11-08
oh gawd, i can only imagine.
-4 hotakyuu 2012-11-08
Well, way to turn this from a friendly conversation to an accusatory question.
your answer
NONE.
Have a nice day. :)
5 [deleted] 2012-11-08
Asking a question is hardly accusational!
No need to downvote, it was a serious question, one that has obviously made you squirm.
-5 hotakyuu 2012-11-08
Someone downvoted my original comment, can only assume it was you ;) EDIT how cute, thanks for undoing that.
6 [deleted] 2012-11-08
I haven't downvoted anyone.
6 [deleted] 2012-11-08
I am downvoting you, because you act like a pussy.
2 [deleted] 2012-11-08
If it makes you feel better then downvote away.
1 [deleted] 2012-11-08
I downvote what deserves to be downvoted.
0 evenmoretiredoflibs 2012-11-08
k
0 hotakyuu 2012-11-08
Don't be a little bitch lol
-2 tttt0tttt 2012-11-08
The only posters I'd want banned are those who advertise commercial products, and those who deliberately and persistently follow and harass other posters because of their opinions.
By that I mean, those who pop up every time a particular poster makes a post, and come forth with the same personal insults against that poster. It's not that hard to recognize targeted personal harassment when you see it repeatedly.
Also, now that I think about it, I'd ban all the bots. The one that keeps posting long strings of links really gets on my nerves. One or two links is useful, but 20 or 30 is just spam.
Other than these categories, I can't think of anything remotely on topic that I want banned from this subreddit. One of the great things about this subreddit, and probably a reason it is so popular, is that people are permitted to voice politically incorrect opinions.
0 hotakyuu 2012-11-08
oh gawd, i can only imagine.
4 [deleted] 2012-11-08
Agreed. However this is the nature of this subreddit. Racism is one thing and opinion and free thought are the other. This is where downvoting and upvoting have to come into play.
I don't have to agree with what an individual says, but they do have the right to say it, and argue their point don't they?
2 [deleted] 2012-11-08
Yes, but you aren't automatically Jewish for being a Zionist, nor are you automatically a Zionist for being Jewish.